Saint Laurent Cassandre Small Tassel Crossbody Bag vs. Maison Martin Margiela I.D. Bracelet Clutch: The Medium or the Masses?

Saint Laurent Cassandre Small Tassel Crossbody Bag vs. Maison Martin Margiela I.D. Bracelet Clutch

Recently, Cathy Horyn succinctly wrote of her longtime nemesis, Hedi Slimane and his accomplishments (or lack thereof) at the house of Yves Saint Laurent: “In two years as creative chief, he has barely broken a sweat as he fetches another pussy bow from the ’60s time capsule.” While this may be true, one can still not deny Slimane’s victory in reviving the brand’s success, awareness, and mass desirability. (Do you think any of the young girls sporting sporting the Cassandre Tassel Bag even know who Stefano Pilati is?)

I’ve often written of the unfair and increasing demands on the modern designer, though the struggle between “art” and business is age-old and ongoing. As critics, we naturally demand high fashion and creativity from designers. Then again, without a high degree of wearability or relatability to their clothes, how are they to sustain their art? Few designers have continuously struck this balance as well as the prolific Miuccia Prada, and she is a rare breed. Commercial success, once scoffed at by “real” designers, is now the primary measuring tool of your craft. And not only are they to turn out four seasons worth of collections a year, they are expected to regularly tweet, post on Instagram, and make public appearances.

I remember when Tom Ford first entered the House of YSL, and during the course of his reign, nary a glaring logo was to be found on a single bag. The Mombasa, a slightly structured, softly rounded, and subtly pleated bag topped with a perfectly sculpted horn handle (some were made of deer antler), captured my heart. Ford’s time at Gucci saw the brand from bankruptcy to a $10 billion conglomerate at the date of his departure in 2004. Clearly, times have changed and logos trump inventiveness. Banal? I have to say yes.

That’s why I currently prefer the likes of always-off-beat Maison Martin Margiela (take their I.D. Bracelet Clutch, for example) and the handcrafted artisanal work of Hermès, and do not currently own a new YSL bag (or Saint Laurent, as Slimane insists the brand be referred to). But I also love a great high-street find. I don’t believe the two are mutually exclusive, that you have to ultimately pick one or the other. Individual choices: that’s the hallmark of great fashion for me. Speaking of choices, do you think the democracy of fashion has gone too far? I have to say maybe so. Saint Laurent Cassandre small tassel crossbody bagicon, on back order at Neiman Marcus, $1750, and Maison Martin Margiela I.D. Bracelet clutchicon, $2,675, at Barneys New York.

9 Comments

  1. August 31, 2014 / 4:34 am

    I really enjoyed your article. I remember when I first saw the YSL Mombasa horn bag, I skipped a heart beat. My daughter still wears it and it looks amazing!
    I am not getting the logo mania trend… but I never say never…
    Love the Maison Martin Margiela ID clutch but for 2,600 I would probably get a Celine.
    x Nina
    http://trendsurvivor.com

  2. Kathryn McQuater
    August 31, 2014 / 9:11 am

    The YSL bag wins!! It is beautiful!!

  3. Melnaie
    August 31, 2014 / 11:36 am

    YSL is my go to counter when I want something new, but I haven’t found anything heart stopping for the past two seasons. I would go for the Margiela ID clutch, only because it so reminds me of High School boyfriends ID bracelets, that were so coveted… but for that price, I will probably pass… the balance of having two in college this fall.. sigh..

  4. August 31, 2014 / 11:30 pm

    I’ve had a YSL bag for over a decade and it never let me down. Still classy and trendy, people keep asking me where I bought it in the street.

  5. August 31, 2014 / 11:41 pm

    I prefer the YSL, simply for the design (I have a soft spot for a tassel), and I would still prefer it to the MMM ID clutch without the logo. I do agree however that the philistine masses want the logo slapped and smeared across every surface of their bag these days which renders artful design superfluous. It’s sad really.

    http://www.awomanintheworld.com

  6. Ellie
    February 20, 2015 / 7:03 am

    the MMM s to dye for

  7. Ellie
    February 20, 2015 / 7:04 am

    the MMM clutch is to die for, i mean 😉

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.